Cigarettes have been given a wellness makeover on TikTok, where one creator described them as the “plant-based alternative” to vaping. Technically, the tobacco leaf qualifies. But the trouble starts when you set it on fire.

In one TikTok, vlogger Cora Hamilton described cigarettes as “spiritually healthy”. One commenter saw a cigarette break as a chance to “touch grass”. In another video, Mollie Fraser offered her “controversial opinion” that cigarettes are healthier than vapes.

The “plant-based” label has been doing the rounds for a while. Australia’s ABC reported seeing posts describing cigarettes in similar terms as early as January. It’s a neat bit of rebranding for a product usually pictured next to a serious health warning.

The cigarette break as a digital detox

For some creators, the appeal is the ritual. Everest Simmons, 26, posted a TikTok about switching from vaping back to cigarettes that drew 4.2 million views and more than 650,000 likes. In an interview, she described the cigarette break as a chance to leave the room, find company on the porch and have a conversation without phones. It’s a case of the old smoking break being refashioned as a digital detox.

Under Fraser’s video, the conversation turned to how easy it is to keep reaching for a vape. “I never woke up 15 times a night to hit a cigarette,” one commenter wrote. Another pointed to how easy it is to vape discreetly, while a cigarette has a beginning and an end.

Simmons told the New York Post she felt more energetic after the switch and found it easier to catch her breath.

What happens when tobacco burns

Dr Carol Eisenstat, a physician in New Jersey, told the New York Post that nicotine intake and overall health risk are two different questions. “A vape may deliver more nicotine than a cigarette in certain circumstances, but that does not make the cigarette healthier.”

“The vast majority of disease and death from smoking comes from combustion,” addiction medicine specialist Dr Sylvie Stacy told the New York Post. “It’s not the nicotine component itself. When you light dried plant matter on fire and inhale the smoke, you draw in a lot of harmful chemicals, tar, and carbon monoxide into your lungs.”

Smoking causes cancer, heart disease, stroke and lung disease. Carbon monoxide in cigarette smoke reduces the amount of oxygen the blood can carry.

Smoking is a proven cause of cancer, heart disease, stroke and lung disease. Burning tobacco releases thousands of chemicals, including substances that cause cancer.

Cigarette smoke also contains carbon monoxide, which reduces the amount of oxygen the blood can carry. Those risks come with the cigarette whether it’s smoked on a porch with friends or halfway through a night out.

Vapes heat a liquid to produce an aerosol. The NHS says nicotine vaping is far less harmful than smoking because it exposes people to fewer toxins and at lower levels. Nicotine can still cause dependence, and the long-term effects of vaping are still being studied. For adults who smoke, the full benefit comes from switching completely and leaving cigarettes behind.

There’s also evidence that vapes can help people make that switch. An updated Cochrane review published in August found that people using nicotine vapes were more likely to stop smoking for at least six months than those using nicotine replacement products such as patches or gum.