A study of three people vaping in a bar and experiments exposing mice to vape-contaminated fabrics have come under fire over how their findings are used to assess risks to bystanders and children.
Tobacco harm reduction commentator Clive Bates and researcher Dr Roberto Sussman have challenged an Italian indoor air study that supported considering wider restrictions on vaping. Separately, Sussman has examined eight mouse studies investigating the effects of residue left on household materials.
The common question is how closely the experiments capture everyday exposure, and whether the evidence supports the health warnings attached to it.
Three vapers and a roadside comparison
The Italian pilot study, published in Multidisciplinary Respiratory Medicine on 2 November, used a portable AirBeam3 monitor to measure airborne particles during a walk along quieter and busier roads and inside a bar with three people vaping.
Researchers from Milan’s National Cancer Institute recorded an average fine-particle concentration, known as PM2.5, of 28.8 micrograms per cubic metre inside the bar, with a peak of 84.7. The average was 6.5 times the level on the quieter street and 3.1 times that on the busier street.
They concluded that indoor vaping worsened air quality and supported considering an extension of indoor smoking restrictions. However, they acknowledged that “this study cannot quantify direct health risks”.
Bates challenged the choice of comparison. “Why not a comparison with a bar with no vapers, a restaurant or a shop?,” he asked. “What about comparison with smoking studies?”
His criticism is that comparing a bar with outdoor streets leaves unanswered how its air compares with other indoor settings, including venues where nobody vapes.
He also questioned what the particle readings reveal about the substances people would actually breathe.
What about comparison with smoking studies?
He said: “Vape aerosol is very different to the products of combustion and decayed road surface that make up outdoor PM.”
What the monitor can tell us
Sussman, a physicist and researcher at the Institute of Nuclear Sciences at the National Autonomous University of Mexico, raised further concerns about the measurements.
Sussman said the study monitored three people vaping over 18 minutes but failed to report how many puffs they took or where the monitor was positioned in relation to them.
Those details could affect the readings, he argued. A monitor close to an exhaled plume may record a different concentration from one elsewhere in the room.
Sussman also questioned the suitability of the optical instrument for measuring rapidly evaporating vape droplets. He argued that such instruments can miss droplets or miscalculate their size and number, making the results difficult to interpret.
His objection extends to treating those droplets as equivalent to the particles found in traffic pollution. He said their chemical composition and behaviour differ, including how long they remain airborne.
Bates also highlighted differences in exposure time, while recognising that people working in bars have different circumstances from customers visiting briefly.
Together, their criticisms challenge the move from a particle reading to a policy recommendation: what was measured, what it contained and how long people encountered it all need to be considered.
From a mouse cage to a family home
Sussman raises a related concern in his critique of mouse experiments, published on 2 November.
He identified eight studies, four from Australia and four from the United States, examining exposure to what researchers call thirdhand vape aerosol. This refers to material deposited on surfaces after vaping, rather than the airborne aerosol a bystander might inhale.
The experiments generally exposed fabrics, such as towels, carpet or upholstery, to machine-generated vape aerosol. The materials were then placed with mice, allowing researchers to investigate biological effects against control groups given clean materials.
The studies examined outcomes including lung changes, inflammation, blood clotting and cognitive function.
Sussman’s central criticism concerns whether the contaminated fabrics and the animals’ contact with them represent conditions children encounter at home.
In his assessment, the available evidence has not established comparable residue exposure in ordinary homes where day-to-day vaping takes place. He argues that laboratory effects can’t establish those real-world risks without that connection.
Hundreds of puffs onto household fabrics
One of the studies he examines, published in Tobacco Induced Diseases in 2024, exposed household materials to 400 puffs a day. Mice then lived with the treated materials for four months, with the materials exchanged weekly.
The researchers reported changes in platelet activity and faster clot formation in their experimental tests. Platelets are blood components that help form clots.
Sussman questions the relevance of the exposure used to produce those findings. His critique describes two studies by the same research team loading fabrics with 2,000 puffs over five days in a small chamber.
He argues that combining this concentrated exposure with a powerful device and high-nicotine liquid creates conditions far removed from ordinary household vaping.
He also raises concerns that the device settings and airflow could cause overheating, potentially changing the chemicals deposited on the fabrics. That is his assessment of the experimental setup, rather than a demonstrated measurement of overheating in those studies.
Missing details make results harder to assess
Other experiments attract criticism for providing too little information about how their aerosol was generated.
Sussman says essential details include the device, coil resistance, power, puff duration and airflow. Without them, it becomes harder to reproduce an experiment or judge whether the aerosol resembles what consumers inhale and exhale.
“Vaping aerosol is not a generic ‘black box’ to be used with arbitrary parameters for exposing mice,” he writes.
Three Australian studies used a KangerTech NEBOX, a device released in 2015, according to his review. He questions its relevance to more recent consumer products and criticises the use of liquid containing 18 milligrams of nicotine per millilitre with these higher-output devices.
In one of those studies, published in 2023, researchers placed a freshly exposed cotton towel in each mouse cage daily for four weeks. They reported lung changes, including enlarged air spaces and, in the nicotine group, changes to airway structure.
Sussman’s challenge concerns how the exposure was created and what those animal findings can tell us about children living with adults who vape.
The dose reaching a child
The route of exposure creates another complication. Mice repeatedly groom themselves, licking material from their fur. Sussman argues that this behaviour can produce a pattern of ingestion and skin contact that differs from human exposure.
He also questions attempts to recreate exhaled aerosol simply by diluting machine-generated aerosol and adding moisture. He says this does not reproduce the retention of substances in a person’s respiratory system before they exhale.
For surface residue, he emphasises that the amount detected on a fabric does not by itself establish how much enters someone’s body. Skin contact area, duration, frequency and body weight all affect the dose.
He acknowledges that toddlers’ prolonged contact with fabrics and repeated hand-to-mouth behaviour warrant particular attention.
Across both critiques, the demand is for evidence that connects the experimental measurements to the exposure people actually experience. Sussman argues that warnings about vaping need that link, particularly when findings are used to justify treating it like smoking.