Michaël Weber, a senator for Moselle, has asked France’s economy ministry whether it has assessed that risk before backing tighter EU rules.

In a written question published on 12 November, he said France had supported banning flavours other than tobacco during discussions on revising the EU Tobacco Products Directive on 6 October. The Senate’s record lists his question as awaiting a ministerial reply.

Buyers could turn to websites and social media

Weber said the proposed restriction was intended to protect under-18s and prevent nicotine addiction. His concern is that buyers could find the same flavours through websites or social media sellers operating outside the rules, making it harder to check what is in the liquid, how strong it is or where it came from.

Sellers could also sidestep age checks, undermining one of the reasons for the ban in the first place.

The senator said it was “crucial to ensure that the proposed restrictions do not lead to an increased circulation of non-compliant products”. He asked whether ministers had assessed the risk of a black market developing alongside the potential effects on businesses and tax revenues.

Weber also asked whether the government would strengthen age verification, tighten rules on marketing and imagery that appeal to children, and give customs officers more resources to tackle illegal sales. He wants ministers to say whether they are considering limiting vape sales to authorised outlets.

French vape businesses warn of a hit to jobs

Weber cited French vaping industry figures that put direct employment at around 10,000 jobs. The industry estimates that around 70 per cent of the e-liquid consumed in France is made there and that businesses independent of tobacco companies account for 85 per cent of the market.

If France sticks to the position it took in October, Weber wants to know whether ministers would offer support to affected businesses and workers.

France’s position is part of a wider EU debate over how to update tobacco rules. In April, the European Commission published its evaluation of the existing Tobacco Products Directive and Tobacco Advertising Directive, examining how well they protect public health and support the EU’s single market.

The EU’s current rules cap nicotine strength in e-liquids at 20 milligrams per millilitre and limit nicotine refill bottles to 10 millilitres. Manufacturers and importers must also tell national authorities what ingredients their products contain before putting them on sale.

The directive leaves decisions on vape flavours to individual countries. A tobacco-only rule would bring that choice under EU-wide regulation.

What a flavour ban could mean for smokers trying to quit

Regulated nicotine vapes give adults who smoke an effective way to quit cigarettes. An updated Cochrane review found that, for every 100 people who used nicotine vapes to quit, around eight to 10 could be expected to stop smoking for at least six months, compared with around six using nicotine replacement products such as patches or gum.